States and nations compared. The case of Kosovo and Ukraine versus global politics
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/1508-1117.17.12Keywords:
emerging countries, international recognition, Kosovo, Ukraine, international crisisAbstract
The 2008 proclamation of Kosovo’s independence, quickly recognized by many states including almost every single one of the western world, showed that a respected international legality does not exist anymore. In fact, in the eyes of the so-called “international community” Kosovo’s secession, pursued by the Albanian majority despite the resistance of the local Serbian nationality (including Belgrade’s government’s efforts against it) and the minority ethnic groups (Goranis, Roma) is a fait accompli that the community itself supported. However, Kosovo’s case is to be interpreted as a dangerous precedent that can endanger the territorial integrity of many states with national minorities aspiring to secession. This happened despite the existence of international law that does not allow unilateral acts of territorial secession, but only the eventuality of commonly agreed political separations. Examples of this kind could be the attempted secession of the eastern regions from the Ukrainian state, and the successful secession of Crimea from Kiev (that was successful also due to Russia’s support). Such initiatives were supported by Russia and opposed by the West, with an inversion of roles completely opposite to Kosovo’s case, that could be described as the other side of the same coin – with roles reversed – compared to the Ukrainian crisis: in Kosovo it was the West (the USA and most of the EU) that considered favorably – if not actually supported – the Albanian secession from Belgrade, while on the other hand Russia has presented itself in the role of the guardian of international legality while supporting the legitimacy of Serbia’s sovereignty rights over Kosovo.
References
Bagnato S., 2011, Kosovo: ancora fumo dalla polveriera d’Europa, [w:] Eurasia. Rivista di studi geopolitici, http://www.eurasia-rivista.org (dostęp: 4.10.2011).
Google Scholar
Battista C., 2011, I Balcani nella strategia politica dell’Occidente dalle guerre alla democrazia 1991–2010, Caserta, Eiffel.
Google Scholar
Borgen C., 2009, The Language of Law and the Practice of Politics: Great Powers, Small States, and the Rethoric of Self-Determination in the Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia, „Chicago Journal of International Law”, 10(1), St. John’s University School of Law, Faculty Publications, Paper 115, s. 1–33, http://scholarship.law.stjohns.edu/faculty_publications/115
Google Scholar
Brewer E.M., 2012, To Break Free from Tyranny and Oppression: Proposing a Model for a Remedial Right to Secession in the Wake of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion, „Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law”, 45, s. 245–292.
Google Scholar
Janicki W., 2014, Relocating International Borders: The Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia Confronted, [w:] Moraczewska A., Janicki W. (red.), Border Conflicts in the Contemporary World, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Marii Curie-Skłodowskiej, Lublin, s. 95–106.
Google Scholar
Janjić D., 2013, Kosovo, vacilla la strategia di Belgrado, www.osservatoriobalcani.org (dostęp: 20.11.2013).
Google Scholar
Qerini Q., Krasniqi S., 2013, Theories and Practice of State Succession to Bilateral Treaties: The Recent Experience of Kosovo, [w:] „German Law Journal”, 14(9), s. 1639–1660.
Google Scholar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S2071832200002455
Lazarević T., 2013, Kosovo del nord, un voto tormentato, www.osservatoriobalcani.org (dostęp: 17.12.2013).
Google Scholar
Lazarević T., 2014, Nord del Kosovo, un anno dall’accordo di Bruxelles, www.osserva toriobalcani.org (dostęp: 6.06.2014).
Google Scholar
Limes, 2014, ‘La Federazione Russa non è la Russia e Putin non è lo zar’. Intervista di Lucio Caracciolo ad Aldo Ferrari, [w:] „Limes”, 5, s. 67–73.
Google Scholar
Loi M., 2013, Il Kosovo, qualcosa in più di un quadro bicolore, [w:] Europae. Rivista di affari europei, www.rivistaeuropae.eu (dostęp: 28.08.2013).
Google Scholar
Martino F., 2014, Kosovo: beyond the „Brussels Agreement”, Analysis no. 254, May 2014, www.ispionline.it/sites/default/files/pubblicazioni/analysis_254_2014.pdf
Google Scholar
Meller S.E., 2012, The Kosovo Case: An Argument for a Remedial Declaration of Independence, [w:] „Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law”, 40, s. 833–866.
Google Scholar
Milano E., 2013, Formazione dello stato e processi di state-building nel diritto internazionale. Kosovo 1999–2013, Editoriale Scientifica, Napoli.
Google Scholar
Romano S., 2014a, Patto d’associazione con Kiev troppa politica, poca ekonomia, „Corriere della Sera”, 04.07.2014, s. 33.
Google Scholar
Romano S., 2014b, Una Candida Arroganza, „Corriere della Sera”, 11.07.2014, s. 1.
Google Scholar
Sii E., 2014, Ucraina: Russia, Assemblea Generale ONU definisce “non valido” il referendum della Crimea, www.atlasweb.it/2014/03/28/ucraina-russia-assembleagenerale-onu-definisce-non-valido-il-referendum-della-crimea-579.html
Google Scholar
Urrutia Libarona I., 2012, Territorial integrity and self-determination: the approach of the International Court of Justice in the advisory opinion on Kosovo, Revista d’Estudios Autonòmics I Federals, no. 16, s. 107–140.
Google Scholar
Violante A., 2010, Lo status del Kosovo e l’Unione Europea, [w:] Violante A., Vitale A., L’Europa alle frontiere dell’Unione. Questioni di Geografia storica e di Relazioni internazionali delle periferie continentali, Unicopli, Milano, s. 193–207.
Google Scholar
Violante A., 2014, The Contrast between Priština and Belgrad in Northern Kosovo, a Region of a Non-sovereign State, [w:] Moraczewska A., Janicki W. (red.), Border Conflicts in the Contemporary World, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Marii Curie- -Skłodowskiej, Lublin, s. 133–150.
Google Scholar
Vitale A., 2009, Frammentazione della sicurezza e guerra preventiva, [w:] Bilotta B.M., Cappelletti F.A., Scerbo A. (red.), Pace Guerra Conflitto nella società dei diritti, Giappichelli, Torino, s. 261–295.
Google Scholar
Zawilski V., 2014, The Political Geography of War in the New World Order, [w:] Moraczewska A., Janicki W. (red.), Border Conflicts in the Contemporary World, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Marii Curie-Skłodowskiej, Lublin, s. 81–91.
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.